Monday, October 31, 2016

Just How Old Is Thanos Anyways?

Just How Old Is Thanos Anyways?

In Abandoned an' Forsaked, we examine comic book stories and ideas that were not only abandoned, but also had the stories/plots specifically “overturned” by a later writer (as if they were a legal precedent).


This is one of those instances where the retcon at hand is less explicit than normal, in that it isn't a case where a writer has a character specifically says “Oh that? That didn't really happen,” but more that we are shown that the original story couldn't possibly have happened, so it is an implicit overturning of the original story. That story, as suggested by reader Jef W., is an early odd story about Thanos where, for a moment there, he was a LOT younger than you would expect.


Thanos made his debut in “Iron Man” #55, where we also met Drax the Destroyer. Writer/artist Jim Starlin (script by Mike Friedrich) has Drax explain his connection to Thanos to Iron Man, while also explaining just who Thanos is…


thanosage1


thanosage2


thanosage3


thanosage4


Okay, so here's the weird twist. So Moondragon made her debut an issue before Thanos and Drax, but in a clearly unrelated story by Bill Everett, Mike Friedrich and George Tuska where she was an unrelated villain known as…sigh…Madame McEvil…


thanosage5


Awesome Dylan reference, Friedrich!


Later that year, Steve Gerber brought Madame McEvil over to Daredevil in “Daredevil” #105 (art by Dons Heck and Perlin), where he re-named her Moondragon and now tied her into the Thanos overall story – although not yet part of the whole Drax story. Check out how it was done, though…


thanosage6


thanosage7


thanosage8


thanosage9


See, Moondragon is shown as a CONTEMPORARY of Thanos. That almost certainly did not fit into what Starlin had planned for the character, so a year later, in “Captain Marvel” #32 (by Starlin, Friedrich and inker Dan Green), Starlin gave the definitive origin for Moondragon and Drax, tying them together and making it clear that Thanos was already an adult by the time he caused the death of Moondragon's parents, thus abandoning and forsaking the Gerber story from “Daredevil” #105…


thanosage10


thanosage11


thanosage12


Later writers were more explicit about Thanos being even older, but suffice it to say that is a good deal older than Moondragon.


Thanks for the suggestion, Jef!


If anyone else has a suggestion for a future Abandoned an' Forsaked, drop me a line at brianc@cbr.com!


The post Just How Old Is Thanos Anyways? appeared first on CBR.com.

Former 'Deadpool 2' Director Tim Miller Now Making a 'Sonic the Hedgehog' Movie

Because video game movies are becoming the new superhero movies, we're getting a Sonic the Hedgehog film. And who better to develop it than Tim Miller, who recently has some unexpected time on his hands since quitting the Deadpool sequel. He won't be directing, though - it'll be Jeff Fowler, his Blur Studios colleague, who will be making his directorial debut with this film
Continue reading…

The Gods Can't Be Trusted In Hammer's 'The Mummy' #1 [Preview]

The Mummy #1, by Peter Milligan and Ronilson Freire, begins on a mythical scale and descends to the brutality of the human world, striking a balance between the two even in the few short pages of this preview, and leaving questions about which plane is driving the story.


Continue reading…

Blaming Joker, Police Call in Batman to Combat Creepy Clowns

Blaming Joker, Police Call in Batman to Combat Creepy Clowns

One police department believes it has uncovered the mastermind behind the wave of creepy clown sightings sweeping across the country and beyond: the Joker. Luckily, the cops also know how to get in touch with the perfect guy to handle this menace.


Just in time for Halloween, the Fairport, New York, Police Department posted a message on Facebook revealing Batman is on the case. What's more, the Dark Knight has been given a police uniform and patrol … apparently because his signature costume and vehicle weren't up to snuff.


Courtesy of the Fairport (New York) Police Department

Courtesy of the Fairport (New York) Police Department



BREAKING NEWS FROM FAIRPORT!


The Fairport Police have received a lead in the Crazy Clown epidemic that has been gripping the nation. We have received information that these clowns are the henchmen of . . . you guessed it . . . the Joker.


Since verifying this new information, the Fairport Police Department have recruited the assistance of America's Favorite Caped Crusader, BATMAN! Batman has been given a Fairport Police Uniform and Police Car to be on patrol in the Fairport area on alert for any suspicious activity. Please call 911 if you observe anything suspicious and we will signal Batman from atop the Village Hall where the blue light shines. Have a safe and Happy Halloween from the members of the Fairport Police Department.


The message is accompanied by two photos - one depicting the Bat-Signal projected onto the clouds, and the other a trio of Fairport police officers, one of whom has donned a Batman mask. Or maybe it is the Caped Crusader; it's difficult to tell.


Because this is the internet, a commenter was quick to criticize the police department as a “descrace.” The police department replied, “Our mission was to build bridges with the community that we serve. We apologize, but you have missed our message and the point of this.


It's unclear whether calling on Batman is merely a Halloween gag or an attempt to reassure kids frightened by reports of sightings of “killer clowns.” Earlier this month in England, a “real-life” Batman stepped up to calm the nerves of local children by delivering a video message, saying, “You don't need to worry anymore - Batman's taken care of it.”


Since the first report in August in Green Bay, Wisconsin, sightings of creepy clowns have spread throughout the United States and into Canada, Australia and the United Kingdom. Some police departments and governing bodies have taken clown reports very seriously, with one county in Kansas going so far as to effectively ban clowns until Tuesday, the day after Halloween.


(via Uproxx)



The post Blaming Joker, Police Call in Batman to Combat Creepy Clowns appeared first on CBR.com.

New 'Doctor Strange' Featurette May Open Your Mind to Seeing It in IMAX 3D

It seems like whenever a new blockbuster comes out, it's on the cutting edge of movie technology. Just this month we had the premiere of Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk, filmed on 120-frames-per-second cameras, advertised as Ang Lee's most realistic-looking movie yet. Doctor Strange is also attempting to get into the innovation game, with an IMAX 3D version of the film that, according to the stars, makes it feel like you're actually there watching skyscrapers kaleidoscoping around you.
Continue reading…

Halloween Cast Party: Who Should Star In A 'Legion of Monsters' Movie?

It's Halloween, and I'm celebrating with a special Cast Party featuring Marvel's spooky supergroup, the Legion of Monsters. While the original team was created in the '70s by Bill Mantlo, Frank Robbins, and Steve Gan, I'm mainly drawing inspiration from the more recent Franken-Castle story written by Rick Remender, with art by Tony Moore, Dan Brereton, and more.
Continue reading…

Josie and the Pussycats #2 (EXCLUSIVE PREVIEW)

Josie and the Pussycats #2 (EXCLUSIVE PREVIEW)

As the girls look to play their first gig outside Riverdale, they run into some unexpected complications. Can they bust up a crime ring, help the criminals see the error of their ways, and jump-start the band's music career-all through the power of rock, friendship, and, Melody assures us, entirely legitimate comic book science? You'll have to read to find out!


josie2isaacsvar


josie2lotayvar


josie2mackvar


josie2sohnvar


josie2zullovar


josieandthepussycats_02-1


josieandthepussycats_02-4-5


josieandthepussycats_02-6


josieandthepussycats_02-7


josieandthepussycats_02-8-9


The post Josie and the Pussycats #2 (EXCLUSIVE PREVIEW) appeared first on CBR.com.

Rey and BB-8 Aren't Just Best Friends, They're the Best Hot Toys Star Wars Figures Yet [Review]

After years of holding a number of licenses for various pop culture icons, it seems almost unbelievable that until 2015, Hot Toys didn't have a deal for Star Wars toys. It took the release of Star Wars: The Force Awakens for the Hong Kong company to finally step into the crowded licensing world of Lucasfilm's flagship franchise. In a way, it's a good thing it took such a long time. The license arrived right in that sweet spot of Hot Toys' expertise finally reaching its apex, rather than a decade earlier when the products weren't quite as impressive.
No product better serves that idea than the newly released Star Wars: The Force Awakens Rey and BB-8 set. As thrilling as it has been to see a number of iconic characters like Leia Organa, Han Solo and the numerous Stormtroopers captured with Hot Toys' impeccable eye for detail, the Rey figure is just a marvelous achievement in an action figure from head to toe. Would that all Hot Toys figures could be so great.
Continue reading…

All He Needs Is Hate: A Tribute To The Punisher

On October 30th 1973, Marvel Comics published The Amazing Spider-Man #129, and introduced readers to Frank Castle, The Punisher. Although originally portrayed as an antagonist, The Punisher proved a breakout character for the publisher like few others, and helped launch the enduring popularity of anti-heroes in superhero comics.


Continue reading…

Showtime's 'Penny Dreadful' Lives Again in 2017 Comic Continuation

The minds behind Showtime's Penny Dreadful adamantly insisted they'd made the choice to end the series after Season 3, even as viewers going in had no idea they were witnessing the end. Well, it turns out they weren't! Penny Dreadful will return in 2017 after all, at least in the form of a comic continuation that aptly reflects the series' namesake.
Continue reading…

R. L. Stine Is Writing Comics For Marvel

R. L. Stine Is Writing Comics For Marvel

After writing hundreds of horror novels for young adults and kids, R.L. Stine is set to unleash his specific talents on the world of comics. While specific details remain shrouded in mystery, Stine revealed during an Reddit AMA session that he has a series of comics in the works at Marvel Comics.


“I'm writing a series of comic books for Marvel– my first comics ever,” said Stine when asked if he'd ever considered working in the medium. “But I'm not allowed to talk about them yet.” Marvel has not yet made an official announcement regarding a project with Stine. Marvel did not comment when reached by CBR.


goosebumps-logo


The 73-year-old writer is most known for his line of “Goosebumps” novels, which originally ran from 1992 to 1997, lasting 62 installments. The line has since been revived and continues today. Stine's work has inspired a number of live-action projects as well, including a television series as well as a 2015 feature film starring Jack Black. In the film, Black played a fictionalized version of Stine; the author himself played a teacher named “Mr. Black.” Stine is also known for the teen-oriented “Fear Street” young adult series, which launched in 1989, and the more recent “Mostly Ghostly” novel series.


The post R. L. Stine Is Writing Comics For Marvel appeared first on CBR.com.

Best Cosplay Ever (This Week): Garnet, Mars Attacks, Blastoise, Black Cat And More

In honor of the caped crusaders of the convention scene, ComicsAlliance has created Best Cosplay Ever (This Week), an ongoing collection of some of the most impeccable, creative, and clever costumes that we've discovered and assembled into a super-showcase of pure fan-devoted talent.


This week's selection of the best cosplay ever includes Garnet, Mars Attacks, Blastoise, Black Cat and more.


Continue reading…

Batman's Foes Take Charge in Legion of Collectors Promo

Batman's Foes Take Charge in Legion of Collectors Promo

“Batman's” enemies are the stars of the animated teaser for Funko's next DC Legion of Collectors mystery box, and, and boy are they out for revenge. Adorable revenge.


RELATED: “Batman: The Animated Series” is Coming to Funko's Pop! Line


The vinyl Pop! villains have the caped crusader exactly where they want him in the 30-second short - hanging bound from a rope dangling over vats of mysterious green smoking liquid. But despite taunts from Joker and Catwoman, the Dark Knight avoids a dunking when a Two-Face drops his coin and pulls a lever to bring the Legion of Collectors Batman villains box crashing down instead.



While the exact contents of the box are, of course, a mystery, the Legion of Collectors website assures fans it contains DC Comics and Funko collectibles valued at $50. Previous boxes have included T-shirts, limited-edition DC comic books, pins, badges and, of course, exclusive Funko figures.


However, if you want to grab one, you will have to move fast: The deadline for the Batman Villains box expires at midnight PST on Nov. 1. That's tomorrow, mind you.


Funko and DC partnered in January to launch the Legion of Collectors subscription box service, a year after the company teamed with Marvel Comics for Marvel Collector Corps.


The post Batman's Foes Take Charge in Legion of Collectors Promo appeared first on CBR.com.

'The Walking Dead' Season 8 'Apparently' Casts Maria Bello

It's early enough into The Walking Dead Season 7 that we don't yet know how the major story will unfold in the wake of Negan's rampage. That said. AMC's flagship hit is already looking forward to Season 8, as Max Steel star Maria Bello has “apparently” secured a role in The Walking Dead's 2017 season.
Continue reading…

“Silver Surfer” Glides Through NYC Traffic in New Video

“Silver Surfer” Glides Through NYC Traffic in New Video

YouTube channel PranksvsPranks has posted a video of Jesse Wellens cruising through New York City decked out as the Silver Surfer of Marvel Comics fame.


RELATED: 12 Greatest Comic Book Alien Invasions


Enlisting the help of makeup artist Alexys Fleming and musician Brock Berrigan, Wellens was painted to look like the comic book herald of world-eater Galactus, and then took to the streets. Wellens rode through the streets of the Big Apple atop a silver, electric surfboard.


The video shows Wellens stopping to greet fans, take pictures and features the crowds of New York, even police officers, stopping to take videos of his awesome costume.


RELATED: Is Twice Monthly Twice as Nice?


Check out the video demonstration of Wellens' Silver Surfer below:



RELATED: How Many Faces Can You Recognize From Mike Allred's “Silver Surfer” #5 Cover?


(via io9)


The post “Silver Surfer” Glides Through NYC Traffic in New Video appeared first on CBR.com.

Patton Oswalt's Halloween Costume Makes Other Dads Look Bad

Patton Oswalt's Halloween Costume Makes Other Dads Look Bad

On today, the spookiest of days, many parents are taking their kids trick-or-treating. One parent though, is escalating this tradition to absurdly awesome levels.


RELATED: Patton Oswalt Sums Up the 'Star Wars' Saga in One Elaborate Analogy




RELATED: Patton Oswalt Joins 'MST3K' Reboot In Mad Role


As you can see, comedian Patton Oswalt's daughter Alice wanted to dress as Raven from the Teen Titans for Halloween this year. She evidently made the costume herself. At the age of 7, Alice is already making costumes that could easily go alongside the fabulous cosplay that happens at Comic Cons.


The story gets even more heartwarming when you take into account Mr. Oswalt's costume. That's right, his daughter requested that he dress as Raven's evil dad, the demon lord Trigon. His many-eyed gaze looks pretty evil, but you can tell by his daughter's face that she know's how cool her dad is.


RELATED: Patton Oswalt Talks Spider-Man in the MCU, DC's Film Slate & His Star Wars Filibuster


On the one hand, props to you sir for doing Halloween so well. On the other hand, curses - now parents everywhere are going to have to up their costume game!


The post Patton Oswalt's Halloween Costume Makes Other Dads Look Bad appeared first on CBR.com.

Director Rick Famuyiwa Drops Out of 'The Flash' Movie

Things are not looking good for Warner Bros.' The Flash solo movie. The DC Film already lost its director this past April, and now his replacement has dropped out.


Continue reading…

DC's Catwoman, Prez & The Flintstones Make Election Night Special

DC's Catwoman, Prez & The Flintstones Make Election Night Special

As election day looms on the horizon, DC Comics makes a non-partisan bid for your vote with politically charged stories featuring some surprising characters.


“The Flintstones” #5 from Mark Russell and Steve Pugh sees Fred and Barney haunted by prehistoric war amidst a fraught election cycle. Meanwhile, Selina Kyle pussyfoots into the Gotham mayoral race in “Catwoman: Election Night” by Meredith Finch, Russell, and Shane Davis. That same special features the return of Beth Ross in her role as “Prez” in a new story from Russell and artist Ben Caldwell.


Both issues hit shelves this Wednesday, November 2, just less than a week ahead of the United States' Presidential election.




CBR: What's important to Selina right now. Is she interested in justice? What informs her decisions?


Meredith Finch: Selina takes care of herself, always. In this issue, someone who's had a postive impact on her life-and I don't think there are many who have-is being threatened by the success of a mayoral candidate, should he be elected. Selina decides to do whatever it takes to protect that person. In the course of doing that, she uncovers more than anybody anticipates.


catwoman prez


Tell us a bit about the Cobblepot platform and getting into the head of the Cobblepot speech writer. That's either a really fun or really sinister scene - or maybe both!


Finch: I'm a Canadian, so I sort of get to watch what's going on in the American election scene with a bit less investment than I might have if I were American. I wanted to take the key points being set for by specific candidates and reflect those, make them as outrageous as I could. Penguin is an outrageous character and there are some outrageous things happening anyway. I wanted to reflect that because the worst war criminals in history have said outrageous things at time, quite publically. I didn't want readers to look on Penguin in any way as a good guy in this.


In both the Catwoman story and the Flintstones story, history plays a prominent role. The ironies, the tipping points that inform so much of the future. Is history just a flat circle? Are we just trying to keep ahead of the past?


Finch: Definitely, I do feel like we tend to repeat history. It feels like even for ourselves, our personal history, you feel as if something's resolved only to find you haven't and end up repeating that. It's a lesson learned constantly throughout one's life. I tried to reflect that in this issue and in Selina, too. What's authentic for her arc is that constant reminder not to trust people.


Mark Russell: As far as “The Flintstones” goes, that's exactly what we're seeing, history as a flat circle. The electorate seems to ignore the mistakes of the past in voting for leaders of the future. There are real consequences to that. Most of the policies being proposed, the rhetoric used in an election cycle has been used before. Very little of it is new, much of it recycled, rehashed, reworded. We don't have to look very far in our past to see the consequences of this nationalist or militaristic rhetoric used to excite rallies in a campaign.


What was the realization, the eureka moment, that helped you understand these characters and their motivations, particularly Selina, Beth and the Flintstones ensemble?


Finch: I know it took me a bit to get into Selina's head since she's so different from Wonder Woman. I really tried to look at it in terms of what she wants, her motivations. It really does come down to protecting herself. At the end of the day I think that's something we all can relate to and understand. It's very difficult to let people in, and when you do let people into your life and do invest in them, you extend that circle of protection out to them. As a mom, I recognize that motherlike role in safeguarding someone from her past who did that for her. “You can't protect yourself, so I'm gonna take care of you now.”


flintstones


Russell: In terms of Beth's motivations in the “Prez” portion of the issue, I think it's about her realizing the limits of idealism. You have to be willing to win a battle when it presents itself to you, and that's really what democracy is. Democracy is governing by compramise, governing by getting what you can today and getting something more tomorrow. That's sort of the lesson she has to learn. Even in defeat there's victories to be had. Sometimes you have to use your failures as an advantage in creating change where you can. For the Flintstones, I think the motivation is largely about the personal. Family. Wanting to create a home for you and the people you love. Even in something horrible like war, we are all the sum total of the tragedies that effect out lives. Even tragedy gives birth to our families and the things we really treasure in life.


Mark, is it difficult to write political pastiche more absurd than what's already going on in the meat space, in actual reality?


Russell: Yeah, I'm constantly being outflanked by how crazy things really are. I feel, in a way, it's been liberating though. Nothing I write is too crazy or too off-the-wall, too hyperbolic. All bets are off in 2016.


This chapter of Prez focuses on birth control and second ammendment issues. Is there anxiety in even approaching those issues, or in getting it right.


Russell: I didn't have much anxiety in either sense. I'm kind of a loudmouth; I just say what I think. If there's any anxiety, It's probably on the part of DC or anybody publishing or buying my work. I think if I have any anxiety at all, it's that maybe I'm not being blunt enough. I'm not being clear or forceful enough. Winston Churchill once said that you don't use subtlety to make a point; you use a sledgehammer. That's been my philosophy.


What do you say to those who suggest politics have no place in fiction, that they just want escapism?


Finch: I think that throughout history, what we do, part of the way we defuse intensity of our feelings politically is to put them into satire, put them into whatever the mainstream media type is today. I think that's exactly what we've done. Certainly the “Catwoman” issue, while it's got some political aspects to it, it's also meant to be fun and hint at what's going. We utilize aspects of the [real life] election, but funadamentally it's about the character.


Russell: I feel like it's kind of naive to suggest that politics shouldn't be incorporated into writing fiction because fiction is writing about life. It's writing about things that effected you or wounded you personally. Politics is a big part of life. It's like saying you shouldn't write about romance or sex or disappointment. Of course you should write about politics if that's what you have something to say about. You shouldn't have to write about politics, but you should write about things that are meaningful, things that are really troubling to you. That's where your authenticity as a writer comes from.


The post DC's Catwoman, Prez & The Flintstones Make Election Night Special appeared first on CBR.com.

So Mockingbird Let Phantom Rider Die For No Reason?

So Mockingbird Let Phantom Rider Die For No Reason?

In Remember to Forget, we spotlight comic book stories that I wish we could just forget.


Today, we look at an odd retcon in the final issue of the recent “Mockingbird” ongoing series.


It all started in “West Coast Avengers” #18 (by Steve Englehart, Al Milgrom and Joe Sinnott), when the West Coast Avengers were traveling through time. They were in the Old West when they got ready to leave and suddenly one of the Western heroes, the Phantom Rider (who had seemed a bit too obsessed with Mockingbird in their short time together) abruptly stopped Mockingbird from traveling with the rest of her Avengers teammates!!


mockingbirdhawkeye1


The next issue, the Phantom Rider then drugs Mockingbird to clear out her memories and make her fall in love with him…


mockingbirdhawkeye2


mockingbirdhawkeye3


It works really well…


mockingbirdhawkeye4


It continues to work well the next issue…


mockingbirdhawkeye5


mockingbirdhawkeye6


In the next issue, though, the other Western heroes conspired to break the effects of the drugs on Mockingbird, and when they did, well, she did not take it well…


mockingbirdhawkeye7


This storyline came to a climax in “West Coast Avengers” #23, when Mockingbird tracked Phantom Rider down and then let him die…


mockingbirdhawkeye8


mockingbirdhawkeye9


mockingbirdhawkeye10


mockingbirdhawkeye11


Eventually, Hawkeye found out (by the Phantom Rider himself, who was now a ghost in modern times) that Mockingbird let Phantom Rider die and Hawkeye was a total jerk about it. Not “my wife was practically raped by some dude!” but “my wife let a guy die!” So they decided to divorce.


So anyhow, in the final issue of the current “Mockingbird” ongoing series (by Chelsea Cain, Kate Niemczyk and Rachel Rosenberg), the Phantom Rider showed up again to annoy Mockingbird (he's done that a few times since Mockingbird was revealed to be alive during “Secret Invasion”) and there is a major retcon to the previous storyline.


First up, Phantom Rider is described by Mockingbird as her “ex”…


mockingbirdhawkeye12


And we learn why later in the issue…


mockingbirdhawkeye13


So…huh? What a strange retcon that is. I completely understand wanting to get away from the whole “letting the guy who essentially raped me die which led to my husband wanting to divorce me” part of Mockingbird's past. It's a weird part of her past, to be sure. But you do that by just not getting into it, not by actively bringing the topic back up again. Rather than moving past this story, this is entirely PREDICATED on that old story. It's just altering it to make it so that Mockingbird actively cheated on Hawkeye rather than being drugged and making it so that she let Phantom Rider die because…ummm…anyone? You can debate about whether it's a good idea to erase Mockingbird's past as a victim period (there's an argument to be made that by saying that it is “ridiculous” to believe that Mockingbird could ever do something against her will then you are implying that if someone else WERE drugged into doing something against their will, then clearly they just weren't strong enough to avoid it – which is SLIGHTLY like victim-blaming, but I think that's a bit of a stretch as an argument, so I don't particularly buy it), but whether that's a good idea or not, altering the story so that she just let the Phantom Rider die for the heck of it is just not a good idea. BEST case scenario, it was a pointless alteration.


Chelsea Cain's “Mockingbird” ongoing series has been a blast and I'm sorry to see it go, so one “out there” decision issue at the end isn't a big deal, but I really don't think that this was a good decision and I suspect that future writers will just ignore this change in the future.


If you have a suggestion for a future “Remember to Forget”, drop me a line at brianc@cbr.com


The post So Mockingbird Let Phantom Rider Die For No Reason? appeared first on CBR.com.

'Walking Dead' Review: 'The Well' Runs Dry for Ezekiel's Grand Introduction

'The Walking Dead' soldiers through Season 7 with a trip to “The Well,” but was our first trip to The Kingdom too early a diversion after last week's brutal premiere? How do Ezekiel and Shiva make the grade? Find out in our full review!
Continue reading…

Sunday, October 30, 2016

Why Didn't Steve Rogers Become “Thorized” Upon Lifting Mjolnir?

Why Didn't Steve Rogers Become “Thorized” Upon Lifting Mjolnir?

Comic Book Questions Answered – where I answer whatever questions you folks might have about comic books (feel free to e-mail questions to me at brianc@cbr.com).


Reader Rob N. wrote in to ask why was it that Steve Rogers didn't transform into a Thor-like costume when he picked up Mjolnir?


For years, there was only one person who was ever worthy of picking up Thor's hammer, Mjolnir, and that was, well, Thor.


Walter Simonson changed everything in “Thor” #337 when Beta Ray Bill picked up the hammer and transformed…


beta1


beta2


Notice how Beta Ray Bill changed into basically a variation of Thor.


During “DC vs. Marvel” (by Ron Marz, Peter David, Dan Jurgens, Cluadio Castellini, Joe Rubinstein and Paul Neary), Wonder Woman picked up Thor's hammer and is transformed…


ww1


See how her outfit was, in effect, “Thorized”?


In “Thor” #384, in the future, Dargo Ktor picked up Mjolnir and transformed…


dargo1


dargo2


He, too, was transformed into a variation of Thor.


Okay, so in “Thor” #390 (by the same creative team of “Thor” #384, Tom DeFalco, Ron Frenz and Brett Breeding), Thor and Steve Rogers (then going by the name “The Captain”) are attacked by the forces of Set…


cap1


cap2


cap3


So, why didn't Steve transform into a Thor-ized version of himself? Honestly, I think it's most likely just a mistake. However, if I were to come up with an explanation, these are the best I can come up with/


First, the argument would be that Steve wasn't really lifting up the hammer so much as he was just trying to get it to Thor. In the other three instances, the character had no specific intent when they picked up the hammer (or stick in Beta Ray Bill's case) other than to pick it up and thus, they became a version of Thor. Cap, on the other hand, picked it up just to get the hammer to Thor, so that is why he didn't change.


In the alternative, perhaps it is an issue where Thor was not present when the hammer was picked up by the other people. Thor had been transformed into Don Blake when Beta Ray Bill picked up the hammer, so there was no Thor at the time. Similarly, there was no Thor present in the future when Drago picked up the hammer. Thor was on a different Earth when Wonder Woman got his hammer in DC vs Marvel (he was on, I think, the Marvel Earth while Wonder woman was on the DC Earth – it could have been the other way around).


I would mention that Superman did not transform when he picked up Mjolnir in “JLA/Avengers”, but the enchantment was off of the hammer at the time, so it really doesn't matter (if you did count it, it would work with the above theory, as Thor was present when Superman got the hammer and Superman did not transform into a Thor-esque costume).


So there you go, Rob, TWO possible answers! I think the second one works best.


If anyone else has a question for a future Comic Book Questions Answered, drop me a line at brianc@cbr.com!


The post Why Didn't Steve Rogers Become “Thorized” Upon Lifting Mjolnir? appeared first on CBR.com.